Supreme Court directs Muruatetu judgement be applied in murder cases only

Supreme Court directs Muruatetu judgement be applied in murder cases only

The Supreme Court has directed the Judiciary sentencing policy guidelines be revised in tandem with the new jurisprudence in the Muruatetu case.

The direction was issued during the mention of the Muruatetu case where the seven Supreme Court judges said the Muruatetu judgement can only be applied in murder cases.

The Muruatetu judgement delivered in 2017 by the Supreme Court declared the mandatory death sentence unconstitutional for the offence of murder.

Many inmates who are currently behind bars for various offences have been relying on the Muruatetu case to get lesser sentences.

“The decision of Muruatetu can only apply for murder under section 203 and section 204 of the penal code,” the court heard.

Further, the seven judge bench led by Chief Justice Martha Koome directed that all offenders who have been subjected to the mandatory death sentence and desire to be heard on sentence will be entitled to resentencing hearing.

Similarly, the apex court issued guidelines in which the court should consider when re-sentencing among them age of the offender, whether the accused pleaded not guilty, character of the offender, manner in which the offence was committed on the victim, possibility of reform and any other factor the court may consider relevant.

“We direct other capital offences like robbery with violence that are challenged on the constitutional validity should be bargained at the high court… Muruatetu can’t be applicable to those cases,” said the court.

Where an appeal is pending at the Court of Appeal or High Court, they will entertain an application for resentencing upon being satisfied that the appeal had been withdrawn.

Meanwhile, the court had its inaugural sitting Tuesday morning with Chief Justice Martha Koome and justice William Ouko sitting for the first time.

During the sitting, the Office of Director of Public Prosecution, Attorney General and the senior Counsel offered their support to the apex court and urged the court to deliver justice.

“I wish to confirm that as an office we endeavor to pursue inter -agency to the delivery of justice,” said Alexander Muteti for DPP.

Representing the senior counsels, Fred Ojiambo read a verse from the book of Deuteronomy urging the bench not to accept bribe , not to allow external factors disrupt them but to do justice.

On her part CJ Martha Koome said the judges will remain independent and impartial as directed by the Constitution.

“I wish to assure Kenyans that the Supreme Court and its judges don’t live in ivory towers. We are part of the Kenyan society and we are acutely aware of the burden of nurturing social transformation that the Constitution has imposed on us… You will allow us to speak mainly through our judgments and not to respond to matters that are not before us,” she said.


death sentence supreme court Muruatetu case

Leave a Comment


No comments yet.

latest stories